You are here: Home / Focus Topics / Housing / Housing Best Practices / "You Don't Have to Live Here:" Why Housing Messages Are Backfiring and 10 Things We Can Do About It

"You Don't Have to Live Here:" Why Housing Messages Are Backfiring and 10 Things We Can Do About It

Background

The following is from: The FrameWorks Institute

If there's anything that's clear at this moment in US history, it's that having a policy window doesn't guarantee policy change.

Take the issue of housing. Advocates have been able to ride a growing tide of public anxiety about housing costs to bring the issue to the attention of policymakers at the city, state, and federal levels. Yet a new analysis, conducted by the FrameWorks Institute with Enterprise Community Partners, suggests that even at the local level this momentum could stall, or face a serious setback, unless advocates reconsider current messaging.

"You Don't Have to Live Here:" Why Housing Messages Are Backfiring and 10 Things We Can Do About It teases out the implications of in-depth insights into how the public thinks about affordable housing, particularly in relation to issues such as economic mobility and racial equity. The main recommendation: To understand how to connect housing issues to the concerns of the public in new ways, advocates must first understand why current messages are failing and backfiring. The analysis found several "backfires" that are blocking progress:

  • Americans hold a shared belief in Self-Makingness--- the idea that personal decisions are the primary reason for individuals' success or failure in securing affordable housing. This explains why even the most compelling stories about people facing housing challenges tend to backfire.
  • Because many Americans believe that policy doesn't play a role in racial disparities, messaging about race can lead people to a Not-In-My-Backyard response to some affordable housing initiatives.
  • The latest data, on their own, aren't enough to change the conversation. Because of confirmation bias, there's always a risk of the Facts Don't Fit the Frame backfire.

On this issue and others, there is much work to be done to move the public toward widespread support for progressive policies. In the months ahead, FrameWorks will delve deeper into the communications aspects of affordable housing, using an innovative mix of social science methods to arrive at an evidence-based framing strategy. In the meantime, "You Don't Have to Live Here" offers insights that advocates can apply now.

 

"You Don't Have to Live Here:" Why Housing Messages Are Backfiring and 10 Things We Can Do About It

Social Media
Follow openBEAM on Twitter

Community Status/News

Search more Beam status ...

January 20, 2021: Coalition of Asian-American Leaders (CAAL)

Redefining wealth through communal & cultural assets and July newsletter: need for data disaggregation on Asian CORID impact metrics.

Read more ...

January 14, 2021: Health Needs Assessment and Planning

Coalition of Community Health Improvement (CHIP) releasing 2021-2023 health improvement plan. 

Read more ...

January 01, 2021: City of Rochester, MN

Unify branding of City departments and teammates

Read more ...

January 01, 2021: Targeted Business, Workforce Participation and Prevailing Wage Strategies

2020-12-11 Report; 2020-11-02 October Report; 2020-09-30 September Report 

Read more ...

December 23, 2020: Minnesota Humanities Center (MHC)

(1) Make a Gift 2020 (2) Legacy Arts and Cultural Heritage Funds, MHC will award grants to American Indians and nonprofit organizations led by Native peoples, and immigrants and nonprofit organizations led by immigrants.

Read more ...

December 10, 2020: Discovery Walk Co-designing

Summary of Co-design of Discovery Walk and Codify the co-design process. 

Read more ...

December 04, 2020: OpenBeam

OpenBeam presentation to CMRC yesterday. 

Read more ...

Search more Beam status ...

Top Beam COVID Info

Destination Medical Center (DMC) : Destination Medical Center (DMC) Plan 5 Year Update

November Newsletter, 5 Year Plan Update draft, webinars on land investments, DMC status and Covid impacts. Reminder to comment on 5 year plan update 

Read more ...

Minnesota Department of Health : Mental Health Well-being During COVID

MN Children's Cabinet Info and Info shared by April Sutor, Family Service Rochester: MDH Shared Resources: Check out MDH websites for resources on mental well-being during COVID. Sites may be updated frequently.

Read more ...

Olmsted County Public Health Services : Rochester Community Warming Center

The Rochester Community Warming Center (200/204 4th Street SE in Rochester) is gearing up for the start of its winter season in a larger space.

Read more ...

Non-profit Consortium Buildout : Nonprofit COVID-19 Response Structure and Social Determinants of Health

(1) Consortium resources have been temporary redirected to cross-sector COVID-19 response planning in the Rochester are. Please contact Brooke with questions. 

(2) System approach for Social Determinants of Health

Read more ...

Council on Asian Pacific Minnesotans (CAPM) : COVID-19 Survey and Resource List

In the last month we have seen an influx of challenges and barriers affecting our API communities during the COVID-19 pandemic. One of the challenges we are hearing from our communities is the closure of schools and the implementation of distance learning.

 As of this current school year, Asian American students make up 6.9% of students enrolled in Minnesota. In the last month, we have heard that language access, technology challenges, and financial burdens have presented barriers not only for students to be successful in the classroom, but also for parents who wish to be involved in their children’s education. This has led our communities to face unique barriers to full and equal participation in learning and instruction during the COVID-19 pandemic.

 In response to this issue, the Council has created a community survey to identify ongoing barriers experienced by API families during distance learning. The purpose of this survey is to collect data collect to inform the Minnesota Department of Education (MDE) on areas for improvement and best practices with API students during the distance learning period.

 With this in mind, we ask for your participation in helping us to widely distribute this survey to community members to ensure that their voices are heard by MDE officials. The survey will be open for community response between Monday, April 27th – Friday, May 8th. 

 During this time of COVID-19, we understand that many organizations have limited capacity, and greatly appreciate any support you can provide in getting this survey out to families.  Our simple ask to you is your help in sending out the survey to community members using email and social media. If you can make this small commitment, please confirm by responding to this email. Once we receive your confirmation we will follow-up with language templates and guidance to send out the surveys. Thank you all and we all wish your loved ones well.

 Please if you have any questions you can contact me, or our Research Assistant Daniel Yang, at daniel.y.yang@state.mn.us.

 Sincerely,

 Anjuli Cameron 

 Anjuli Mishra Cameron, M.S. | Research Director

Council on Asian Pacific Minnesotans | 658 Cedar Street, Suite 160 | St. Paul, Minnesota 55155

(651) 757-1742 |  (507) 649-1157 | anjuli.cameron@state.mn.us |mn.gov/capm

 

 

 

Looking for additional resources during the COVID-19 outbreak? 


 

Read more ...

Health Needs Assessment and Planning : Health Assessment and Planning

March 2020 Olmsted County Health Assessment & Planning Process (HAPP) Meeting Recap

Read more ...